Friday, November 25, 2016

Star Wars Reference (Redux): Character Ages

EDITED 12/5/2024 Changed title from "Age Comparisons." Reorganized by media. Actor ages are only included for live-action portrayals or if a character's age isn't canonically known.
CANON
The Acolyte (132 BBY) [filmed in 2022-2023]
Sith
    Mae and Osha Aniseya: 24 (Amandla Stenberg: 24-25)
    The Stranger / Qimir: ?? (Manny Jacinto: 35-37)
Jedi
    Sol: ?? (Lee Jung-jae: 50-51)
    Yord Fandar: ?? (Charlie Barnett: 34-35)
    Indara: ?? (Carrie-Anne Moss: 55-56)
    Jecki Lon: 18 (Dafne Keen: 18-19)
    Vernestra Rwoh: 116 (Rebecca Henderson: 42-43)
Episode I The Phantom Menace (32 BBY) [filmed in 1997]
Jedi
    Qui-Gon Jinn: 60 or 48 (Liam Neeson: 45)
    Obi-Wan Kenobi: 25 (Ewan McGregor: 26)
    Anakin Skywalker: 9 (Jake Lloyd: 8)
    Mace Windu: 40 (Samuel L. Jackson: 49)
    Depa Billaba: ?? (Dipika O'Neill Joti: 30)
    Adi Gallia: ?? (Gin Clarke: ??)
    Ki-Adi-Mundi: 60 (Silas Carson: 32)
Naboo
    Padme Amidala: 14 (Natalie Portman: 16)
    Quarsh Panaka: 30~39 (Hugh Quarshie: 43)
    Sio Bibble: ?? (Oliver Ford Davies: 58)
    Sabe: 14 (Keira Knightley: 12)
    Eirtae: 13~19 (Liz Wilson: 18)
    Rabe: ?? (Cristina da Silva: 22)
    Sache: 12 (Sofia Coppola: 26)
    Yane: ?? (Candice Orwell: ??)
Republic
    Sheev Palpatine: 50 or 52 (Ian McDiarmid: 53)
    Finis Valorum: ?? (Terrence Stamp: 59)
    Sei Taria: ?? (Kamay Lau: ??)
Episode II Attack of the Clones (22 BBY) [filmed in 2000]
Jedi
    Anakin Skywalker: 19 (Hayden Christensen: 19)
    Obi-Wan Kenobi: 35 (Ewan McGregor: 29)
    Mace Windu: 50 (Samuel L. Jackson: 52)
    Barriss Offee: 18 (Nalini Krishan: 23)
    Aayla Secura: 26 (Amy Allen: 24)
    Shaak Ti: ?? (Orli Shoshan: 26)
    Luminara Unduli: 36 (Mary Oyaya: ??)
Republic
    Padme Amidala: 24 (Natalie Portman: 19)
    Sheev Palpatine: 60 or 62 (Ian McDiarmid: 56)
    Bail Organa: 45 (Jimmy Smits: 45)
Separatists
    Dooku: 80 (Christopher Lee: 78)
Fringe
    Jango Fett: 44 (Temuera Morrison: 40)
The Clone Wars (22-19 BBY)
Jedi
    Anakin Skywalker: 19-22
    Obi-Wan Kenobi: 35-38
    Ahsoka Tano: 14-17
Republic
    Padme Amidala: 24-27
    Mon Mothma: 26-29
Separatists
    Dooku: 80-83
    Asajj Ventress: 28-31
Mandalorians
Fringe
    Boba Fett: 10-13
    Aurra Sing: 29-32
Episode III Revenge of the Sith (19 BBY) [filmed in 2003]
Jedi
    Anakin Skywalker: 22 (Hayden Christensen: 22)
    Obi-Wan Kenobi: 38 (Ewan McGregor: 32)
    Mace Windu: 53 (Samuel L. Jackson: 55)
    Aayla Secura: 29 (Amy Allen: 27)
    Shaak Ti: ?? (Orli Shoshan: 29)
    Luminara Unduli: 39 (Fay David: ??)
    Zett Jukassa: 10 (Jett Lucas: 10)
Republic / Empire
    Padme Amidala: 27 (Natalie Portman: 22)
    Bail Organa: 48 (Jimmy Smits: 48)
    Wilhuff Tarkin: 45 (Wayne Pygram: 44)
    Chi Eekway: ?? (Katie Lucas: 15)
    Mon Mothma: 29 (Genevieve O'Reilly: 26)
    Tannon Praji: 41 (John Knoll: 41)
    Terr Taneel: ?? (Amanda Lucas: 22)
Separatists
    Dooku: 83 (Christopher Lee: 81)
Sith
    Darth Sidious: 63 or 65 (Ian McDiarmid: 59)
Others
    Breha Organa: Mid-30s (Rebecca Jackson Mendoza: 30)
Jedi: Fallen Order (14 BBY) ["filmed" in 2018]
Stinger Mantis crew
    Cal Kestis: ?? (Cameron Monaghan: 25)
    Cere Junda: ?? (Debra Wilson: 56)
    Merrin: 18-19 (Tina Ivlev: ??)
Empire
    Darth Vader: 27
    Second Sister: ?? (Elizabeth Grullon: 25)
Solo (13-10 BBY) [filmed in 2017]
Main
    Han Solo: 19-22 (Alden Ehrenreich: 28)
    Lando Calrissian: 33 (Donald Glover: 34)
    Qi'ra: 18-21 (Emilia Clarke: 31)
    Tobias Beckett: ?? (Woody Harrelson: 56)
Cloud-Riders
    Enfys Nest: 17 (Erin Kellyman: 19)
    Weazel: ?? (Warwick Davis: 47)
Crimson Dawn
    Maul: 44 (Ray Park: 43)
    Val: ?? (Thandiwe Newton: 45)
Obi-Wan Kenobi (9 BBY) [filmed in 2021]
    Obi-Wan Kenobi: 48 (Ewan McGregor: 50)
    Luke Skywalker: 10 (Grant Feely: )
    Leia Organa: 10 (Vivien Lyra Blair: 9)
Empire
    Darth Vader: 32 (Hayden Christensen: 40)
    Reva Sevander: 22 (Moses Ingram: 27)
Others
    Owen Lars: 43 (Joel Edgerton: 47)
    Beru Lars: 38 (Bonnie Piesse: 38)
    Bail Organa: 58 (Jimmy Smits: 66)
    Breha Organa: ?? (Simone Kessell: 46)
Andor (5 BBY)
Rebels
    Cassian Andor: 28- (Diego Luna: 42-) 
    Maarva Andor: 77 (Fiona Shaw: 63-64)
    Saw Gerrera: ?? (Forest Whitaker: 60)
Empire
    Syril Karn: 35 (Kyle Soller: ??)
Rebels (5-1 BBY)
Spectres
    Kanan Jarrus: 28-32
    Hera Syndulla: 24-28
    Ezra Bridger: 14-18
    Sabine Wren: 16-20
Rebel Alliance
    Ahsoka Tano: 31-35
Empire
    Thrawn: 54-58
Rogue One (1-0 BBY)
Rogue One
    Jyn Erso: 20-21 (Felicity Jones: 32)
    Cassian Andor: 32-33 (Diego Luna: 36)
    Chirrut Imwe: 51-52 (Donnie Yen: 52)
    Baze Malbus: 52-53 (Jiang Wen: 52)
    Bodhi Rook: 24-25 (Riz Ahmed: 34)
Rebel Alliance
    Galen Erso: 55-56 (Mads Mikkelsen: 50)
    Davits Draven: 44-45 (Alistair Petrie: 45)
    Antoc Merrick: 45-46 (Ben Daniels: 51)
Empire
    Orson Krennic: 50-51 (Ben Mendelsohn: 46)
    Wilhuff Tarkin: 63-64 (Guy Henry: 55)
Partisans
    Saw Gerrera: ?? (Forest Whitaker: 54)
Others
    Lyra Erso: 34 (Valene Kane: 28)
Episode IV A New Hope (0 BBY) [filmed in 1976]
Rebel Alliance
    Luke Skywalker: 19 (Mark Hamill: 25)
    Leia Organa: 19 (Carrie Fisher: 20)
    Han Solo: 29 or 32 (Harrison Ford: 34)
    Wedge Antilles: 21 (Denis Lawson: 29)
    Biggs Darklighter: 24 (Garrick Hagon: 37)
Jedi
    Obi-Wan Kenobi: 57 (Alec Guinness: 62)
Empire
    Darth Vader: 41 (David Prowse: 41)
    Wilhuff Tarkin: 64 (Peter Cushing: 63)
    Conan Antonio Motti: 35-39 (Richard LeParmentier: 30)
    Cassio Tagge: ?? (Don Henderson: 45)
    Nahdonnis Praji: 37 (George Roubicek: 41)
Episode V The Empire Strikes Back (3 ABY) [filmed in 1979]
Rebel Alliance
    Luke Skywalker: 22 (Mark Hamill: 28)
    Leia Organa: 22 (Carrie Fisher: 23)
    Han Solo: 32 or 35 (Harrison Ford: 37)
    Lando Calrissian:
    Wedge Antilles: 24 (Denis Lawson: 32)
Empire
    Darth Vader: 44 (David Prowse: 44)
    Kendal Ozzel: ?? (Michael Sheard: 41)
    Firmus Piett: 42 (Kenneth Colley: 42)
Fringe
    Boba Fett: 35 (Jeremy Bulloch: 34)
Episode VI Return of the Jedi (4 ABY) [filmed in 1982]
Rebel Alliance
    Luke Skywalker: 23 (Mark Hamill: 31)
    Leia Organa: 23 (Carrie Fisher: 26)
    Han Solo: 33 or 36 (Harrison Ford: 40)
    Lando Calrissian:
    Wedge Antilles: 25 (Denis Lawson: 35)
    Mon Mothma: 52 (Caroline Blakiston: 49)
    Crix Madine: 38 (Dermot Crowley: 35)
Jedi
    Anakin Skywalker: 45 (Sebastian Shaw: 77)
Empire
    Darth Vader: 45 (David Prowse: 47)
    Firmus Piett: 43 (Kenneth Colley: 45)
The Mandalorian (9 ABY)
Mandalorians
    Din Djarin: ?? (Pedro Pascal: 43-)
    Bo-Katan Kryze: ?? (Katee Sackhoff: 39-)
Jedi
    Luke Skywalker: 28
    Ahsoka Tano: 45 (Rosario Dawson: 40)
Empire
    Gideon: 60 (Giancarlo Esposito: 61-)
    Gilad Pellaeon: 60 (Xander Berkeley: 66-67) {assuming Legends age is Canon)
Fringe
    Greef Karga: 71 (Carl Weathers: 70-74)
    Fennec Shand: ?? (Ming-Na Wen: 55-)
The Book of Boba Fett (9 ABY)
Ahsoka (9 ABY) [filmed in 2022]
Jedi
    Ahsoka Tano: 45 (Rosario Dawson: 43)
    Sabine Wren: 30 (Natasha Liu Bordizzo: 28)
    Ezra Bridger: 28 (Eman Esfandi: ??)
New Republic
    Hera Syndulla: 38 (Mary Elizabeth Winstead: 38)
    Jacen Syndulla: 10 (Evan Whitten: ??)
Empire
    Thrawn: 68 (Lars Mikkselsen: 58)
Skeleton Crew (9 ABY?)
Episode VII The Force Awakens (34 ABY) [filmed in 2014]
Resistance
    Rey: 19 (Daisy Ridley: 22)
    Finn: 23 (John Boyega: 22)
    Poe Dameron: 32 (Oscar Isaac: 35)
    Leia Organa: 53 (Carrie Fisher: 58)
    Han Solo: 66 (Harrison Ford: 72)
    Lor San Tekka: 79 (Max von Sydow: 85)
    Kaydel Ko Connix: 21 (Billie Lourd: 22)
    Jessika Pava: ?? (Jessica Henwick: 22)
Jedi
    Luke Skywalker: 53 (Mark Hamill: 63)
First Order
    Kylo Ren: 29 (Adam Driver: 30-31)
    Armitage Hux: 35 (Domhnall Gleeson: 31)
    Phasma: 28 (Gwendoline Christie: 36)
Resistance (34 ABY)
Resistance
    Kazuda Xiono: 20
    Torra Doza: 16
Episode VIII The Last Jedi (34 ABY) [2017]
Resistance
    Rey: 19 (Daisy Ridley: 24)
    Finn: 23 (John Boyega: 24)
    Poe Dameron: 32 (Oscar Isaac: 37)
    Rose Tico: 23 (Kelly Marie Tran: 27)
    Leia Organa: 53 (Carrie Fisher: 59-60)
    Kaydel Ko Connix: 21 (Billie Lourd: 24)
    Tallie Lintra: 22 (Hermione Corfield: 23)
    Paige Tico: 28 (Veronica Ngo: 37)
Jedi
    Luke Skywalker: 53 (Mark Hamill: 65)
First Order
    Kylo Ren: 29 (Adam Driver: 32)
    Armitage Hux: 35 (Domhnall Gleeson: 33)
    Phasma: 28 (Gwendoline Christie: 38)
Episode IX The Rise of Skywalker (35 ABY) [filmed in 2018-2019]
Resistance
    Rey: 20 (Daisy Ridley: 26-27)
    Finn: 24 (John Boyega: 26-27)
    Poe Dameron: 33 (Oscar Isaac: 39-40)
    Leia Organa: 54 (Carrie Fisher: n/a [archival footage])
    Kaydel Ko Connix: 22 (Billie Lourd: 26-27)
    Beaumont Kin: 40 (Dominic Monaghan: 42-43)
    Rose Tico: 24 (Kelly Marie Tran: 29-30)
    Wedge Antilles: 56 (Denis Lawson: 71-72)
First Order
    Kylo Ren: 30 (Adam Driver: 35-36)
    Armitage Hux: 36 (Domhnall Gleeson: 35-36)
    Enric Pryde: 62 (Richard E. Grant: 61)
Sith Eternal
    Darth Sidious: 119 (Ian McDiarmid: 74)
Fringe
    Zorii Bliss: 34-36 (Keri Russell: 42-43)
Others
    Dathan: 33 (Billy Howle: 29)
    Miramir: 27 (Jodie Comer: 25)
LEGENDS
Knights of the Old Republic (3956 BBY)
Party
    Carth Onasi: 38
    Mission Vao: 14
    Zaalbar:
    Canderous Ordo: 58
    Bastila Shan:
    Juhani: At least 17
    Jolee Bindo:
Knights of the Old Republic II: The Sith Lords (3951 BBY)
Party
    Kreia:
    Atton Rand: 29-32
    Bao-Dur:
    Brianna: 25
    Visas Marr: 25
    Mical: 25
    Mira: 23
The Old Republic (3640 BBY)
Jedi Knight party
    Kira Carsen: 20
    Doc: 28
    Fideltin Rusk: 40
    Scourge: 300+
Jedi Consular party
    Tharan Cedrax: 29
    Qyzen Fess: Unknown
    Nadia Grell: 22
    Felix Iresso: 31
    Zenith: 36
Republic Trooper party
    Elara Dorne: 26
    Aric Jorgan: 30
    Tanno Vik: 34 (possibly)
    Yuun: 28
Smuggler party
    Bowdaar: 197
    Corso Riggs: 22
    Risha: 21
    Akaavi Spar: 28
    Languss Tuno: 33
Sith Warrior party
    Pierce: 29
    Malavai Quinn: 37
    Vette: 21
    Jaesa Willsaam: 21
Sith Inquisitor party
    Talos Drellik: 27
    Andronikos Revel: 35
    Xalek: 24
    Ashara Zavros: 20
Imperial Agent party
    Kaliyo Djannis: 29
    Vector Hyllus: 26
    Eckard Lokin: 65
    Raina Temple: 24
Bounty Hunter party
    Torian Cadera: 18
    Mako: 19
    Gault Rennow: 54
    Skadge: 37
Jedi
    Satele Shan: 59
Republic
    Nasan Godera: 67
    Ardun Kothe: 54
Sith
    Darth Baras: 57
    Darth Jadus: 45
    Darth Malgus: 60
    Darth Marr: 62
    Darth Thanaton: 55
    Darth Vowrawn: 76
Sith Empire
    Rycus Kilran: 51
Jedi Knight: Dark Forces II (5 ABY) [filmed in 1996 or 1997]
Rebels
    Kyle Katarn: 28 (Jason Court: 33-34)
    Jan Ors: 29 (Angela Harry: 33-34)
Jedi
    Qu Rahn: ?? (Bennet Guillory: 47-48)
Empire
    Jerec: ?? (Christopher Neame: 49-50)
    Sariss: ?? (Valerie Wildman: 43-44)
    Yun: 22 (Rafer Weigel: 27-28?)
Jedi Knight II: Jedi Outcast (12 ABY)
Jedi
    Kyle Katarn: 35
Jedi Knight: Jedi Academy (14 ABY)
Jedi
    Kyle Katarn: 37
    Jaden Korr: ??
COMICS
Knights of the Old Republic (3964-3962 BBY)
Main
    Zayne Carrick: 18-20
    Jarael: 24-26
Jedi
    Lucien Draay: 36-37
Crucible
    Chantique: 26-27
Knight Errant (1032 BBY)
Jedi
    Kerra Holt: 18
Legacy (137-138 ABY)
Mynock crew
    Cade Skywalker: 21-22
Jedi
    Shado Vao: 21-22
Empire
    Roan Fel: mid-50s
    Marasiah Fel: 18-19
    Nyna Calixte / Morrigan Corde: 40
Canon
The High Republic: Phase II (382 BBY)
Jedi
    Vildar Mac: 55
The High Republic: Phase I (232-230 BBY)
The High Republic: Phase III (229 BBY-)
NOVELS
Legends
The Old Republic
Revan (3954-3950 BBY)
Deceived (3653 BBY)
Fatal Alliance (3643 BBY)
    Shigar Konshi: 18
    Satele Shan: 56
    Eldon Ax: 17
Annihilation (3640 BBY)
Knight Errant (1032 BBY)
Jedi
    Kerra Holt: 18
Sith
    Vilia Calimondra: 70
    Arkadia Calimondra: 25
    Daiman: 25
    Dromika & Quillan: 14
Darth Bane Trilogy (1000-980 BBY)
    Darth Bane: 26-46?
    Darth Zannah: 10-30
The New Jedi Order (25-29 ABY)
Jedi
    Jacen Solo: 16-20
    Jaina Solo: 16-20
    Anakin Solo: 15-17
    Luke Skywalker: 44-48
    Mara Jade Skywalker: 42-46
    Kyp Durron: 32-36
    Corran Horn: 43-47
    Zekk: 18-22
Dark Nest Trilogy (35-36 ABY)
Jedi
    Jacen Solo: 26-27
    Jaina Solo: 26-27
Legacy of the Force (40-41 ABY)
Jedi
    Luke Skywalker: 59-60
    Mara Jade Skywalker: 57 
    Ben Skywalker: 14-15
    Jaina Solo: 31-32
    Seha Dorvald: 18-19
    Valin Horn: 27-28
    Zekk: 33-34
Alliance
    Syal Antilles: 23-24
Sith / Dark Jedi
    Jacen Solo / Darth Caedus: 31-32
    Alema Rar: 30
Fate of the Jedi (43-44 ABY)
Jedi
    Ben Skywalker: 17-18
    Jaina Solo: 34-35
    Seha Dorvald: 21-22
    Valin Horn: 30-31
    Jysella Horn: 27-28
Sith
    Vestara Khai: 16-17
Canon
The High Republic: Phase II (382 BBY)
Jedi
    Enya Keen: 20
    Gella Nattai: 30
    Creighton Sun: 40
Republic
    Dietrix Jago: 20
The High Republic: Phase I (232-230 BBY)
Jedi
    Avar Kriss: 30-32
    Vernestra Rwoh: 16-18
    Bell Zettifar: 18-20
The High Republic: Phase III (229 BBY-)
Jedi
    Avar Kriss: 33-
    Vernestra Rwoh: 19-
    Bell Zettifar: 21-
ORIGINAL TRILOGY
Rebel Alliance
Lando Calrissian
    TESB: 46 (Billy Dee Williams: 42) [34 in Legends]
    ROTJ: 47 (Billy Dee Williams: 45) [35 in Legends]
    TROS: 78 (Billy Dee Williams: 81)
Jan Dodonna
    R1: ?? (Ian McElhinney: 67)
    ANH: ?? (Alex McCrindle: 65)
Garven Dreis
    ANH: ?? (Drewe Henley: 35-36)
Davish Krail
    ANH: ?? (Graham Ashley: 49)
Dak Ralter
    TESB: 20 (John Morton: 32)
Carlist Rieekan
    TESB: 50 (Bruce Boa: 49)
Mon Mothma
    ANDOR: 43-48 (Genevieve O'Reilly: 43-44)
    R1: 48 (Genevieve O'Reilly: 38)
    MANDO: 57 (Genevieve O'Reilly: 45)
Airen Cracken
    ROTJ: 50 (Michael Stevens: ??)
Empire
Palpatine / Darth Sidious
    OWK: 73 (Ian McDiarmid: 77)
    ROTJ: 86 (Ian McDiarmid: 38)
Wullf Yularen
    ANDOR: (Malcolm Sinclair: 71)
    ANH:
Lorth Needa
    TESB: ?? (Michael Culver: 41)
Maximilian Veers
    TESB: 47 or younger (Julian Glover: 44)
Tiaan Jerjerrod
    ROTJ: 39 (Michael Pennington: 39)
Fringe
Boba Fett
    AOTC: 10 (Daniel Logan: 13)
    ANH: 32
    ROTJ: 36 (Jeremy Bulloch: 37)
    MANDO: 41 (Temuera Morrison: 59-)
Others
Owen Lars
    AOTC: 30 (Joel Edgerton: 26)
    ROTS: 33 (Joel Edgerton: 29)
    ANH: 52 (Phil Brown: 60)
Beru Lars
    AOTC: 25 (Bonnie Piesse: 17)
    ROTS: 28 (Bonnie Piesse: 20)
    ANH: 47 (Shelagh Fraser: 56)
PREQUEL TRILOGY
Jedi
Ki-Adi-Mundi
    AOTC: 70 (Silas Carson: 35)
    ROTS: 73 (Silas Carson: 38)
Zett Jukassa
    AOTC: 7 (Jett Lucas: 7)
Jocasta Nu
    AOTC: ?? (Alethea McGrath: 80)
Luminara Unduli
    ROTS: 39 (Fay David: ??)
Olana Chion
    ROTS: 25 (Dominique Chionchio: ??)
Republic
Bail Organa
    R1: 67 (Jimmy Smits: 60)
Sheltay Retrac
    ROTS: 21 (Caroline de Souza Correa: 24)
Sith
Darth Maul
    TPM: 22 (Ray Park: 23)
Fringe
Aurra Sing
    TPM: 19 (Michonne Bourriague: 19)
Naboo
Sio Bibble
    AOTC: ?? (Oliver Ford Davies: 61)
    ROTS: ?? (Oliver Ford Davies: 64)
Ruwee Naberrie
    AOTC: 55 (Graeme Blundell: 55)
Jobal Naberrie
    AOTC: 54 (Trisha Noble: 56)
Sola Naberrie
    AOTC: 28 (Claudia Karvan: 28)
Dorme
    AOTC: ?? (Rose Byrne: 21)
Apailana
    ROTS: 13 (Keisha Castle-Hughes: 13)
Others
Shmi Skywalker
    TPM: 40 (Pernilla August: 39)
    AOTC: 50 (Pernilla August: 43)
Weazel
    TPM: ?? (Warwick Davis: 27)
Dannl Faytonni
    AOTC: 54 (Anthony Daniels: 54)
Cliegg Lars
    AOTC: 60 (Jack Thompson: 60)
SEQUEL TRILOGY
Resistance
Caluan Ematt
    TFA: 54 (Andrew Jack: 70)
    TLJ: 54 (Andrew Jack: 72)
Snap Wexley
    TFA: 45 (Greg Grunberg: 48)
    TLJ: 45 (Greg Grunberg: 50)
    TROS: 46 (Greg Grunberg: 52)
Korr Sella
    TFA: 22 (Maisie Richardson-Sellers: 22)
Amilyn Holdo
    TLJ: ?? (Laura Dern: 49)
Sith Eternal
Chesille Sabrond
    TROS: 30 (Rochenda Sandall: 30)
Others
Jannah
    TROS: 20-23 (Naomi Ackie: 26)
LIVE-ACTION SHOWS
Dark Jedi
Baylan Skoll
Shin Hati
    MANDO: ?? (Ivanna Sakhno: 25)
Others
Leida Mothma
    ANDOR: 13 (Bronte Carmichael: )
GAMES
Jedi
Cal Kestis
    JFO: 18 (Cameron Monaghan: 25)
    JS: 23 (Cameron Monaghan: 29)
Cere Junda
    JFO: ?? (Debra Wilson: 56)
    JS: ?? (Debra Wilson: 60)

No comments:

Post a Comment